• | |

    Armageddon 2001 Reading Order & Review: Who’s Monarch? (1991)

    1991. While DC Comics was launching the Wonder Woman-related War of the Gods crossover event, another, less impressively scaled one was coming to a close: Armageddon 2001. It was one of those events published across many annuals. These tend to be forgotten, but this one was surrounded by enough controversy over its conclusion to leave its mark on comics history as a case study in how not to deal with your ending leaking in the press.

    Created by writer Archie Goodwin and artist Dan Jurgens and brought to a close by editor and writer Dennis O’Neil, this event introduced several notable characters, making it hard for DC fans (and completists) to miss. Despite the controversial ending, Armageddon 2001 had a strong concept to begin with that would easily satisfy fans of Elseworlds stories. So let’s take a closer look (and in order, please)!

    Read More “Armageddon 2001 Reading Order & Review: Who’s Monarch? (1991)”
  • Opening the DC Casebook

    We all have to start somewhere. When it comes to comic books, you just pick one up and read. If you like it and want more, that’s when things may get complicated if you are reading comics published by the “Big Two.”

    There are already pretty complete guides available on the web that will help you read more. My ambition with the DC Casebook is to do that and more. As I navigate through hordes of reading orders, I get lost between series and characters. There are so many. What do I really need to read? And why?

    It’s positioning yourself to fail to try to answer that, as even if we would like to believe the opposite, the people behind the comics do not have a master plan, and the way the industry works doesn’t allow for one anyway. So, I can at least try to go to what matters and help readers like myself get an understanding of what they are reading and how to move beyond one part of the DC Comics Universe to the other.

    Yes, it’s all about DC Comics here. I began reading comics via Marvel superheroes, but DC Comics is where I found a place that felt more in tune with my sensibilities. More mysteries, more adult-themed books (I’m a Vertigo fan), a bigger openness to risk (at least, from time to time), and a place where my favorite authors and artists found their voices.

    This blog is envisioned as a long-running project, probably years of work, so don’t forget to bookmark it so you can find it again!

  • My Complete DC Roadmap: Key Runs, Events, and Milestones

    Navigating nearly nine decades of DC Comics can feel less like diving into a universe and more like trying to map an infinite multiverse without a compass. Since Action Comics #1 debuted in 1938, so many creators have contributed to stacked timelines on top of resets, birthed golden-age legends, spun off dark-fantasy imprints, and launched cosmic-level crises. For seasoned fans seeking forgotten gems or new readers overwhelmed by where to begin, the sheer volume of material often makes knowing what to read the hardest part of the journey.

    That’s exactly the problem I faced recently (at the time of writing) while exploring possibilities for my next reading project for DC Casebook. As a result, I started looking into essential creator runs, historical milestones, monumental events, and obscure gems that shaped DC Comics history, from the sci-fi boom of the Silver Age to the mature dread of Vertigo and the modern ever-expanding universe. It soon spun out of control. What I came up with is what I call my DC Roadmap. It’s not exhaustive. It’s not definitive either. It’s full of runs, a lot I have not read, too. I just dig into the DC Comics catalog to look for books with a good reputation. I also tried to cover many of the big characters, because I have the ambition to read about some I barely know about.

    Simply put, it’s my way of getting a grasp on the evolution of the DC Universe, a tentative blueprint for the very best, or at least the most intriguing, DC has to offer. I’m open to more suggestions. The roadmap will never end.

    🚩Note on the organisation of the list: It’s not strictly chronological in terms of reading order, as I based it on start and end dates without giving it much further thought. When I explore a run, I’ll write a guide, but in the meantime, consider this a starting point, nothing more.

    Read More “My Complete DC Roadmap: Key Runs, Events, and Milestones”
  • Green Lantern Case File: Emerald Twilight (1994) – The Fall of Hal Jordan (Review + Reading Guide)

    It all started at the end of the “Reign of Supermen” saga, in 1993. Mongul decimated Coast City (in Green Lantern #46!). Hal Jordan’s hometown and everyone in it were a thing of the past, and Earth’s Green Lantern wasn’t ready to let anything go.

    This catastrophic event paved the way for what was one of the most controversial storylines in time: Emerald Twilight. A hero broke bad, lost his mind, and committed horrible acts of violence. This story, written by Ron Marz with art by Bill Willingham, Fred Haynes, and Darryl Banks, opened the way for a new Green Lantern, Kyle Rayner, while Hal Jordan became the cosmic threat Parallax. It’s now considered a classic, so let’s dig into it!

    Read More “Green Lantern Case File: Emerald Twilight (1994) – The Fall of Hal Jordan (Review + Reading Guide)”
  • A Complete Batman Post-Crisis Reading Order a.k.a. The Modern Age (Work in Progress)

    Welcome to the world of the Dark Knight. Undeniably one of DC Comics’ most popular characters, Batman has a long and editorially complex history. With a blog like DC Casebook, it’s hard not to go through the biggest case of all: the ultimate Batman Reading Order. And by Ultimate, I mean a Bat-Family Reading Order. While most of the similar works are focused on Batman alone, because sane people are making them, I have the crazy ambition to cover the whole extended family. Which makes this project even more complicated.

    It will take time. I’m talking about years. But I will eventually compile my own version of a complete reading guide for Batman. For now, it’s very much a Work in Progress! So, let’s begin with the Batman Post-Crisis era, also known as the Modern Age.

    Read More “A Complete Batman Post-Crisis Reading Order a.k.a. The Modern Age (Work in Progress)”
  • |

    Countdown to Final Crisis Reading Order: The Year the Multiverse Fractured

    Published between 2007 and 2008 by DC Comics, Countdown to Final Crisis was designed as the weekly lead-in to Final Crisis, following in the publishing model established by 52. Running for 51 issues, the series attempted to lay the groundwork for the next major crisis in the DC Universe while following multiple parallel storylines involving cosmic threats, multiversal instability, and several major DC characters.

    Things didn’t turn out as well as with 52. It was a massive editorial blunder. As Grant Morrison explained it at the time: “Final Crisis was partly-written and broken down into rough issue-by-issue plots before Countdown was even conceived, let alone written.” But despite that, the writing led by Paul Dini seems to lack enough details to not contradict what would eventually happen in Final Crisis. As a result, plotlines in Countdown had diverged so much that continuity between the two publishing initiatives became partly nonsensical. Some elements complement Final Crisis and add a greater understanding of the end story, but most do the opposite. Characters who died end up alive (and are killed again), and whole storylines are redone in Final Crisis, and the overall tone doesn’t fit. If you add to that Death of the New Gods by Jim Starlin, to which Countdown began to respond before veering away from it, the confusion became maddening.

    Today, Countdown to Final Crisis is a complicated affair to deal with for readers. If you are a completist, you can’t skip it. Idem if you are trying to follow some secondary characters. Ultimately, this is widely considered to be non-canonical.

    Read More “Countdown to Final Crisis Reading Order: The Year the Multiverse Fractured”
  • The Else-Files: A review of JSA: The Golden Age (1993) by James Robinson and Paul Smith

    The Justice Society of America was first assembled in late 1940 and stayed active for a good decade. Today, they eventually came back and had a long history until Zero Hour: Crisis in Time put an end to it… Before the ground was laid for a comeback in a new form, one that relied heavily on legacy characters. James Robinson played a key role with his Starman series. Before that, though, he went back to the late 1940s to reframe the JSA’s collapse as part of the changing times in post-WWII America.

    JSA: The Golden Age is an Elseworlds story. A four-issue miniseries (each issue is double-sized, though) pencilled by Paul Smith and colored by Richard Ory. It’s not part of DC’s main continuity. Still, I think it’s a good introduction to the JSA and Robinson before jumping into Starman, especially since the series echoes some ideas surrounding Ted Knight (the original Starman).

    Read More “The Else-Files: A review of JSA: The Golden Age (1993) by James Robinson and Paul Smith”
  • The Batman Case Files: Scott Snyder’s Batman: The Black Mirror (Review)

    If you revisit Batman’s adventures as the Modern Age was about to end, you realise the New 52 reboot wasn’t planned too far in advance. Even in late 2010, mere months before the end of the era, many storylines were being set in motion to take the characters in new, intriguing directions.

    It was a time when Bruce Wayne was doing some globe-trotting, recruiting more Batmen throughout the world to fight an impending menace as well as helping local vigilantes stop criminals. At home, in Gotham City, Dick Grayson was Batman, patrolling familiar rooftops alongside his Robin, Damian Wayne.

    It was then that writer Scott Snyder made his DC Comics debut on Detective Comics, working with artists Jock and Francesco Francavilla. Now simply known as “The Black Mirror”, his 11-issue run showed he had what it takes to go further, and this led him to become Batman’s lead writer during The New 52. So, let’s take a look at his early work in the Dark Knight universe.

    Read More “The Batman Case Files: Scott Snyder’s Batman: The Black Mirror (Review)”
  • Is John Byrne’s Superman Still Good? A 2026 Retrospective Review

    In 1986, John Byrne undertook the challenging project of reimagining Superman as a relatable contemporary figure. This involved making some controversial decisions. He abandoned the optimism of the Silver Age in favour of a more psychologically grounded interpretation, shaped by the cultural logic of the 1980s. It was criticized by some for being Superman for adults. Four decades later, does it still resonate, or was it purely a product of its time?

    While later interpretations have emphasized Superman as a near-mythical ‘space god’, Byrne’s work is the most notable ‘human-first’ reimagining of the character. It established the modern Lex Luthor and a proactive, credible Lois Lane, but it also led to a Superman who violated his own moral code in a conclusion that remains controversial. Whether regarded as a necessary modernization or a fundamental misreading of the character, Byrne’s influence continues to shape virtually every screen adaptation of Superman.

    Although I have read DC Comics for decades, I was never particularly interested in Superman. To broaden my understanding of the character, I approached this landmark series from a contemporary perspective. So, in this review, we’re looking past the nostalgia.

    Read More “Is John Byrne’s Superman Still Good? A 2026 Retrospective Review”
  • Legends (1986) Reading Order: The First Post-Crisis Crossover

    In 1986, DC Comics was fresh off the success of Crisis on Infinite Earths. It was a new era with a rebooted universe. After that, the question was: What next? The answer seems to have been “another crossover event.”

    Before we got the Legends we know today, there was “Crisis of the Soul.” This scrapped 12-issue project was designed to show a world turning on its heroes through spiritual corruption. Though canceled after months of development, some of his ideas survived. In August 1986, editor Mike Gold and a star-studded creative team launched Legends. It wasn’t a sequel to Crisis, but an “introduction” to the modern DC Universe.

    Read More “Legends (1986) Reading Order: The First Post-Crisis Crossover”