| |

Armageddon 2001 Reading Order & Review: Who’s Monarch? (1991)

Disclaimer: As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases (Affiliate Disclosure). Thanks!

1991. While DC Comics was launching the Wonder Woman-related War of the Gods crossover event, another, less impressively scaled one was coming to a close: Armageddon 2001. It was one of those events published across many annuals. These tend to be forgotten, but this one was surrounded by enough controversy over its conclusion to leave its mark on comics history as a case study in how not to deal with your ending leaking in the press.

Created by writer Archie Goodwin and artist Dan Jurgens and brought to a close by editor and writer Dennis O’Neil, this event introduced several notable characters, making it hard for DC fans (and completists) to miss. Despite the controversial ending, Armageddon 2001 had a strong concept to begin with that would easily satisfy fans of Elseworlds stories. So let’s take a closer look (and in order, please)!


  1. What is Armageddon 2001 about?
  2. Collecting Armageddon 2001 in 2026?
  3. My review of the event
  4. The complete reading order

🔍 The Premise: The Hunt for the Future Tyrant

The story opens in a dark, dystopian year 2030. The entire planet is ruled by Monarch, a ruthless, armored tyrant who hunted down and slaughtered all of Earth’s superheroes to establish total dominance. A scientist named Matthew Ryder risks his life to test an experimental time-travel device, hoping to prevent Monarch’s rise.

The experiment transforms Ryder into Waverider, a chronal entity that can move through the time-stream and see ten years into a person’s potential future with physical contact. Waverider knows only one thing: Monarch was originally one of Earth’s modern-day superheroes.

Traveling back to 1991, Waverider visits DC’s heroes one by one to look into their potential futures to discover who will become Monarch.

Hawk and Dove (Vol. 3) Annual #2

📚 Collecting Armageddon 2001 in 2026?

It’s not possible! That’s mostly it. DC Comics has not published a complete collected edition of this event yet. Even if you go to DC Universe Infinite, issues are not listed together in one place. You can find Armageddon 2001 #1-2 together there and on Kindle, but you’ll need to track down each tie-in individually.

In the complete reading order section of this article, I’ll link each issue to DC Universe Infinite, if they are available (they are not all available!).

✍️ My Review of Armageddon 2001 and its collection of What… Ifs!

Armageddon 2001 still has a pretty terrible reputation. As a result, I did not expect the first issue to be this strong. Writer Archie Goodwin and artist Dan Jurgens built the dystopian future in a very engaging way. There are some clichés and dated visual elements, but the way Matthew Ryder is introduced via his alienation from Monarch’s society and how it makes him a problem for others creates strong and relatable motivations. I thought this future where everything is fine for everybody who just follows the rules had a lot of potential. I almost hoped for Matthew to wait a bit longer before starting his time-traveling adventure.

But he didn’t. He went on, becoming Waverider through the process, allowing him to travel in 1991. There, he finds heroes, touches them to see if they will eventually become Monarch in the future. Each issue presents a tale about an alternate future, all of it enticing readers to look out for clues about Monarch’s identity. Of course, not all those comics are good, qualitatively speaking, but some are certainly better than others.

The Time Paradoxes

One of the main flaws of Armageddon 2001 is that most futures we see are just possibilities, but not on the same timeline. It’s made abundantly clear in the Hawk and Dove Annual. Then, Batman and Superman go through the process twice with different futures each time. And the final issue even acknowledges it, using it as a way to try to make sense of the whole idea. As a result, even if there’s some fun to be had with the concept, the Waverider’s quest feels useless. Consequently, the whole event feels like that too, to some degree. This is reinforced by the ending.

Whatever future Waverider explores, being only one possibility among many, will he ever find the truth about Monarch? Yes, in the final issue. But between the first and the last, it’s just What… Ifs? comics without consequences. As I said before, some are still good. Far from me is the idea of dismissing the whole event in one full sweep because there is a flaw in its conceit. But I would never recommend it to anyone who just read it for any other reason than learning about the origins of Waverider and Monarch, characters that found their ways in other stories, or the first appearance of Team Titans.

At least, if you stumble onto one issue, you can read it and enjoy it, even without the rest of the events. My favorites are: the humorous Justice League America Annual #5 and Justice League Europe Annual #2, Batman Annual #15 with its murder mystery twist, and the take on President Superman in Action Comics Annual #3.

Armageddon 2001 #2

The Nonsense Ending, a True Editorial Misstep?

The reason Armageddon 2001 stands as one of the most infamous editorial case studies in comic book history is that its ending was rewritten so quickly, nobody seems to have looked into making it make sense. So, what happened?

The story was constructed to point toward Captain Atom as Monarch. However, when the twist leaked before the finale’s publication, editorial decided that surprising the audience was more important than storytelling. The reveal of Monarch’s true identity was swapped at the last minute to Hawk (Hank Hall).

Maybe the hints at Captain Atom could be declared to have been red herrings, but in Hawk and Dove Annual #2, Waverider had already scanned many of Hawk’s futures, showing him explicitly fighting and dying against Monarch! It was the only issue in which the future really takes place in Monarch’s dystopian world. However, even if it’s hard to believe that a character like Hawk would credibly become Monarch, Dennis O’Neil, who wrote the issue, didn’t do such a bad job trying to sell it. The whole temporal logic behind Waverider’s vision of the future was clunky, but using Schrödinger’s observer effect to explain it helped make it sound at least credible in the moment. By looking into the hero’s future, Waverider influenced it.

Still, it all happens so quickly that it sounds almost absurd in the moment. But the more the story progresses, the more it starts to read like a parody. It was necessary to explain how someone like Hawl could defeat all of Earth’s Superheroes, as he clearly did not have the powers to do so. The explanation does not fit in a comic from 1991. It’s more Silver Age style, and not from the top of the line.

It was a mess, and it still is. Armageddon 2001 had a strong start, but it became more of a gimmick before crashing completely.


📜 Complete Armageddon 2001 Issue-by-Issue Reading Order

Follow this reading path to experience the full mystery as published in 1991.

  • Armageddon 2001 #1 – It’s 2030. Monarch is in control, and rebel scientist Matthew Ryder looks for a way to change the world. A new time machine could make his dream a reality, but he needs access.

After that, each issue introduced a possible future for the Superheroes of 1991.

  • Superman (Vol. 2) Annual #3: Superman didn’t dismantle Intergang, who accidentally nuked Metropolis. After that, the Man of Steel destroyed the Nuclear arsenal of the world and stole from rich countries to help the poor ones, but the US government wants him stopped and asks Batman’s help.
  • Batman Annual #15 (collected in Batman: The Caped Crusader Vol. 4): The Joker is sane. Robin quits, and someone starts killing Batman’s enemies. Condemned for crimes he didn’t commit, Batman is in jail, waiting for the truth and the end.
  • Justice League America Annual #5 (Collected in Justice League International Omnibus Vol. 3): Disguised as Captain Atom, Waverider joins the JL after Maxwell Lord has been shot and put in a coma. Everybody is here, waiting for news. Waverider looks into each one of their future.
  • Action Comics Annual #3: Having changed his future once following Waverider’s first visit, Superman is on a new path that will lead him to become President of the United States of America.
  • L.E.G.I.O.N. ’91 Annual #2: While Lobo’s future is the same as his present, Waverider met with Vril Dox, who will become another type of Tyrant.
  • Hawkworld (Vol. 2) Annual #2: Katar Hol had given up the wings to change the system from the inside, but failed. Now, he starts flying again, and Attila makes a comeback.
  • Hawk and Dove (Vol. 3) Annual #2: Waverider looks into Hawk’s future fighting Monarch, and a possible Dove’s future, before seeing how their child could be the key to winning.
  • The Flash (Vol. 2) Annual #4: To put a dangerous criminal in jail, Wally West must testify and join the witness protection program to protect his family. Ten years later, his son’s life is in danger, it’s time to run again.
  • The Adventures of Superman Annual #3: After Lois dies while pregnant, Superman leaves Earth and meets Maxima, who sees an opportunity to get what power and love she seeks.
  • Detective Comics Annual #4: Batman’s war against Ra’s al Ghul reaches a new deadly level. Who will survive?
  • The New Titans Annual #7: In the future, Nightwing led his Team Titans in a battle against dictator Lord Chaos.
  • Justice League Europe Annual #2 (Collected in Justice League International Omnibus Vol. 3): Superman introduces Waverider to the JLE for him to get a peek at their future, which seems to be the past.
  • Armageddon 2001 #2: Exploring Captain Atom’s possible future, Waverider realizes he was played by Monarch, who followed him to 1991.
Armageddon 2001 #2

After Armageddon…

  • Action Comics #670: Monarch’s attack happens in the middle of this issue, which eventually deals with the consequences of the destruction that occurred during the fight.
  • Superman (Vol. 2) #61: Dealing with the wreckage of S.T.A.R. Labs, Superman works with the Metal Men under Waverider’s eyes when a mysterious time-traveling woman takes Superman away to Vanishing Point.
  • Armageddon – Alien Agenda: Following Armageddon 2001 #2, Captain Atom and Monarch are trapped in prehistoric times, facing dinosaurs and aliens. It’s only the start of their trip home through time.
  • Armageddon – Inferno: Waverider has to face Abraxis, the ruler of another dimension, and recruit heroes to help him.

Published nine years later, JSA #14 retconned the ending of Armageddon 2001 by revealing that Mordru is responsible for manipulating Hawk into becoming Monarch.


👉 What’s Coming Next?

Everything didn’t end here. Dan Jurgens, who was the artist on the two main issues of this event, went on to write and draw Zero Hour: Crisis in Time, in which Waverider and Monarch made a comeback. It was his way to deal with continuity problems.

[Proceed to Next Case: Zero Hour]

More Files from the Casebook

  • Green Lantern Case File: Emerald Twilight (1994) – The Fall of Hal Jordan (Review + Reading Guide)

    Disclaimer: As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases (Affiliate Disclosure). Thanks!

    It all started at the end of the “Reign of Supermen” saga, in 1993. Mongul decimated Coast City (in Green Lantern #46!). Hal Jordan’s hometown and everyone in it were a thing of the past, and Earth’s Green Lantern wasn’t ready to let anything go.

    This catastrophic event paved the way for what was one of the most controversial storylines in time: Emerald Twilight. A hero broke bad, lost his mind, and committed horrible acts of violence. This story, written by Ron Marz with art by Bill Willingham, Fred Haynes, and Darryl Banks, opened the way for a new Green Lantern, Kyle Rayner, while Hal Jordan became the cosmic threat Parallax. It’s now considered a classic, so let’s dig into it!

    Read More “Green Lantern Case File: Emerald Twilight (1994) – The Fall of Hal Jordan (Review + Reading Guide)”
  • The Batman Case Files: Introduction to Grant Morrison’s Masterpiece Run (2006-2013)

    Disclaimer: As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases (Affiliate Disclosure). Thanks!

    Grant Morrison’s seven-year run on Batman is widely considered one of the most ambitious long-form epics in the history of modern comic books. Running across multiple titles from 2006 to 2013, the story functions as a massive three-act saga that breaks down Bruce Wayne before rebuilding him on a global scale.

    As it is a big read, this may not be the most inviting entry point for new readers. But it’s one influential run that continues to impress and, at times, leave a little confusion. It’s a dense and coherent narrative driven by big ideas, fueled by deep cuts into obscure DC lore.

    This article presents Grant Morrison’s run, outlining the key ideas, plot points, and characters. It serves as a roadmap providing context for my detailed reading order and retrospective review. So, let’s start exploring this rich case file!

    Of course, Morrison was not alone. During his run, he worked with artists Andy Kubert, J.H. Williams III, John Van Fleet, Tony Daniel, Ryan Benjamin, Lee Garbett, Frank Quitely, Philip Tan, Cameron Stewart, A,dy Clarke, Frazer Irving, Scott Kolins, Chris Sprouse, Ryan Sook, Yanick Paquette, George Jeanty, David Finch, Scott Clark, and Chris Burnham.

    Read More “The Batman Case Files: Introduction to Grant Morrison’s Masterpiece Run (2006-2013)”
  • Flashpoint Reading Order: The End of The Post-Crisis era

    Disclaimer: As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases (Affiliate Disclosure). Thanks!

    As the massive crossover event Crisis on Infinite Earths did in 1985-1986, Flashpoint put an end to another major era of the DC Universe continuity in 2011: The Modern Age. The kind of events comic book companies always teased, but rarely delivered, the ones that really changed everything.

    Written by Geoff Johns and illustrated by Andy Kubert, Flashpoint centers on Barry Allen, the freshly returned Silver Age Flash, who wakes up in a world he doesn’t recognize. In this fractured reality, the Justice League was never formed, Superman is a prisoner of the state, and a genocidal war between Atlantis and Themyscira has brought humanity to the brink of annihilation.

    It’s not just another event to file in the DC Casebook, it’s the one that closed the book on the Post-Crisis era (1986-2011). Published as a five-issue limited series in 2011, it paved the way for the line-wide reboot known as the New 52.

    Read More “Flashpoint Reading Order: The End of The Post-Crisis era”
  • The Black Casebook: Deconstructing the Silver Age Ghosts of Grant Morrison’s Batman

    Disclaimer: As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases (Affiliate Disclosure). Thanks!

    To a reader who is not all too familiar with Batman comics, Grant Morrison’s Batman run can, at times, feel like a fever dream. Why is there a “Bat-Mite”? Who are the “International Heroes”? The answer lies in The Black Casebook, a meta-fictional journal where Bruce Wayne recorded every encounter that defied logic, physics, or sanity.

    When I first read this run, my knowledge of Batman was limited to recent publications. I lacked a broader understanding of what the character went through. Even some recurring characters were not known to me. I caught up quickly, as the stories Morrison wrote don’t require you to be a Dark Knight scholar to be understood, but the more you know, the more you can appreciate what the author did.

    So, in this DC Casebook investigation, we strip away the modern shadows to reveal the 1950s and 60s “Golden & Silver Age” stories that Morrison transformed into psychological pieces to explore the mind of the Bat.

    Read More “The Black Casebook: Deconstructing the Silver Age Ghosts of Grant Morrison’s Batman”
  • |

    Countdown to Final Crisis Reading Order: The Year the Multiverse Fractured

    Disclaimer: As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases (Affiliate Disclosure). Thanks!

    Published between 2007 and 2008 by DC Comics, Countdown to Final Crisis was designed as the weekly lead-in to Final Crisis, following in the publishing model established by 52. Running for 51 issues, the series attempted to lay the groundwork for the next major crisis in the DC Universe while following multiple parallel storylines involving cosmic threats, multiversal instability, and several major DC characters.

    Things didn’t turn out as well as with 52. It was a massive editorial blunder. As Grant Morrison explained it at the time: “Final Crisis was partly-written and broken down into rough issue-by-issue plots before Countdown was even conceived, let alone written.” But despite that, the writing led by Paul Dini seems to lack enough details to not contradict what would eventually happen in Final Crisis. As a result, plotlines in Countdown had diverged so much that continuity between the two publishing initiatives became partly nonsensical. Some elements complement Final Crisis and add a greater understanding of the end story, but most do the opposite. Characters who died end up alive (and are killed again), and whole storylines are redone in Final Crisis, and the overall tone doesn’t fit. If you add to that Death of the New Gods by Jim Starlin, to which Countdown began to respond before veering away from it, the confusion became maddening.

    Today, Countdown to Final Crisis is a complicated affair to deal with for readers. If you are a completist, you can’t skip it. Idem if you are trying to follow some secondary characters. Ultimately, this is widely considered to be non-canonical.

    Read More “Countdown to Final Crisis Reading Order: The Year the Multiverse Fractured”
  • |

    Final Crisis Reading Order: The Day Evil Won (2008)

    Disclaimer: As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases (Affiliate Disclosure). Thanks!

    With Batman R.I.P., Grant Morrison not only wrote the psychological destruction of the Dark Knight, but also paved the way for a new threat menacing the whole DC Multiverse, one that went beyond physical conquest. Final Crisis is the story of the “God of Evil,” Darkseid, finally discovering the Anti-Life Equation and using it to enslave the consciousness of the human race.

    This isn’t a war fought only in the streets, it’s a war fought for the soul of reality. As the “New Gods” of Apokolips fall to Earth and inhabit human hosts, the sky turns red, time begins to collapse, and the heroes of the DC Universe are forced into a final stand against a darkness that has already won.

    Read More “Final Crisis Reading Order: The Day Evil Won (2008)”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *